I got on the uptown W train last night at Union Square. At the same time a young guy boarded my car with a medium-sized brown dog. The dog was on a leash but was hyperactive, jumping all over the place, sitting on its hind legs, darting in and out of its owner’s legs. This was annoying. Dogs are not allowed on the subway, except for seeing-eye dogs and except for those in carriers.
Did the guy just not know, or not care? If he could break the rule, why shouldn’t others break the rules too?
I thought about saying something to him. A few weeks ago I was on an uptown N train and a young Latino guy was playing a boombox fairly loudly. Also against the rules. To my surprise, an older white man came back from where he was sitting farther up in the car with his wife or companion and said simply to the man, shaking his head, “This really isn’t okay.” The young man didn’t say anything but half-rolled his eyes and lowered the volume substantially. In the few seconds before he exited the train at Times Square, he cranked up the volume again, a little jab at the old man I suppose — a bid to restore his coolness. But hey, saying something worked. For a few minutes we all had a quieter ride, the rules were enforced, the young and rebellious were kept in check by authority.
Someone I met recently told me that he had been riding on a D train uptown late at night when a cop came through the car and asked him and a few other guys to get off the train because they had violated the rules. My friend had his legs up on a seat. The cop told him he would be issued a citation and it would be effectively erased from his record, and he wouldn’t have to go to court. But it was a hassle and a humiliation. Sounds like the NYPD is finally enforcing the new subway rules that were intended to create more civility on the subways. But wouldn’t it make more sense to enforce the “no feet on the seats” rule during rush hour, when people actually need the seats, than in the middle of the night?
And more to the point, might it not be better if more people said something to civic offenders, rather than relying on the police to write tickets for such minor infractions? That takes a little guts — you never know how the other person is going to react. But that’s how change happens.